• Home
  • Public notices
    • Bids
  • Voter Information
  • About Us
  • Contact

North East PA Online

For North East Township and North East Borough

  • North East Township
  • North East Borough
  • North East School District
  • Greenfield Township

Ballot Question Asks if Marsy’s Law Should Become an Amendment to PA Constitution

October 23, 2019 by Paul Crowe 2 Comments

A quick glance at the ballots for the upcoming election on November 5th, reveals a question at the end about a proposed constitutional amendment for crime victim rights. Introduced as PA House Bill 276 and commonly referred to as Marsy’s Law, it’s a nationwide effort to specifically add a series of victim’s rights to the various state constitutions. A yes vote means it becomes an amendment, a no vote, it doesn’t.

The answer is obvious, … or is it?

Unless you are in the habit of following legislation very closely, this question may appear to have come out of nowhere and since everyone supports victim’s rights, the yes or no answer might seem obvious, but it’s not quite that simple.

One not so obvious fact is that Pennsylvania already has a crime victims act passed in 1998. This amendment would add very little to those protections and simply duplicate what already exists. Advocates say otherwise and the arguments quickly descend into territory unlikely to be sorted out by anyone unfamiliar with or involved in criminal court proceedings on a daily basis. There is also an interesting background story to the funding for the group, Marcy’s Law for Pennsylvania, that is its primary proponent.

The Pennsylvania League of Women Voters as well as the ACLU of Pennsylvania are suing to stop the passage of this amendment which is also opposed by the Pennsylvania Association of Criminal Defense Attorneys. The Marsy’s Law for Pennsylvania campaign, Governor Wolf and the Pennsylvania District Attorneys Association all support it.

Twelve states have passed Marsy’s Law so far.

The bill has passed both houses of the PA General Assembly for two consecutive sessions and is now on the ballot and if approved by the voters and signed by the governor, who has already indicated his support, it will become an amendment to the PA constitution.

This issue is complex and arguments, both pro and con, are convincing. It would have been helpful if there had been a more robust conversation in public before it showed up on the ballot as a yes or no question.

Filed Under: Elections and voting Tagged With: constitutional amendment, Marsy's Law

  1. Everyone has the right to know what their government is doing.
  2. Transparency is expected in all government meetings and daily operations.
  3. Everyone working in the government works for, and is answerable to, you and me.
  4. All laws, regulations, ordinances, budgets, audits and other public records should be freely available, preferably online, for citizens to examine without special fees and paperwork before they can do so.
  5. When municipalities seek bids for contract work, all bid documents should be available online, free of charge. Printed copies, if requested, should be offered at cost.
  6. Agendas should be posted online a minimum of 3 days before public meetings take place allowing interested citizens an opportunity to hear discussions and offer input on matters important to them.

Like this website? Spread the word. Tell everyone about NorthEastPAOnline.com!

Subscribe to North East PA Online. You will get an email notice when something is new!

« North East Township Meeting Schedule and Agenda Now Published Here
North East School District Requests Refuse Removal, Disposal and Recycling Services Bids »

Comments

  1. Ken says

    October 24, 2019 at 9:01 am

    I’ve read the amendment & support it on its merits. The Clincher: If the League of Women Voters and the ACLU oppose the amendment, then I’m in favor of it.

    Reply
    • Paul Crowe says

      October 24, 2019 at 9:24 am

      The League of Women Voters is against it as presented, however, the amendment has a long list of victim rights all combined into this one up or down vote. They suggest breaking it up into several smaller chunks so support for some doesn’t require support for all and they also refer to PA Supreme Court rulings which seem to back their objection.

      If your support is based on objections by the League and the ACLU, you might also note that Governor Wolf takes the opposite position to theirs and supports it, so it’s not the usual left/right political issue.

      I’m leaning toward support, but it’s not a clear cut case, at least not to me.

      Reply

Comment Policy: We invite your thoughts and ideas so we may have an interesting and civil conversation. Using your real name is preferred, but not necessary, your email is required, but will not be displayed. North East PA Online does not endorse nor imply agreement with any particular comment just because we let it stand, but, you already knew that. Just be nice because profanity and other unhelpful remarks will be removed. Thank you.

Let us know what you think Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Looking for something?


Subscribe to North East PA Online

Be the first to know when something is new!


Borough & Township Ordinances

North East Borough Ordinances
North East Township Ordinances

North East Area Comprehensive Plan



Erie County Report

Doug Mastriano Restore Freedom Rally - Erie Bayfront - October 14th
Remember This Photo From the Erie Airport? Did You Ever See It?

Flags in classrooms


The ONLY flag that should appear
in any public school classroom.

We Support Real Elections

"... one man, one vote, in person, on Election Day, in public, with ironclad voter identification. Absentee ballots should be limited to overseas military personnel only; if you’re out of town or even the country, that’s your choice. There should be no “ballot curing,” drop-off votes, early votes, or judge-mandated late votes."
~ Michael Walsh

North East Sportsmen's Club

Are you a hunter, target shooter or trap shooter? We have an active gun club here in North East. If you would like to join, visit the North East Sportsmens Club website for complete details.

Copyright © 2023 · North East PA Online · Website by Crowe Computer Services
US Army veteran owned and operated
This website proudly Made in the USA!
Made in the USA